The Case of Natalie M.

There is a point in any discussion where everything has been said, but everybody hasn’t yet had a chance to say it. I think that applies to the case of Natalie M, the teacher blogger who got caught complaining about her students on line.

Since I haven’t yet said it, I will proceed, and I will be brief.

First, I am certain that her blog was cherry-picked for negative comments. That is to be expected: people pay attention to bad news. Nobody will remember all the nice things you say and do if you do one really stupid, bad thing.

Second, I believe she has a right to state her opinion. Everyone does. There are consequences, however, and it does not appear as if that possibility occurred to her. She used a public forum and made unprofessional remarks. If she does not lose her job, she has certainly lost her credibility. Teachers are not held to a higher standard than other professionals. I would not go to a doctor who complained online that all his patients were fat, lazy slobs.

Currently teachers are the scapegoats of education. No matter how unmotivated and ill-mannered our students are, we will be blamed for their failure. This isn’t fair, but it’s the reality for now. The truth about our schools needs to be told, but it must be spoken persuasively if we want to bring about change.

Natalie M sees herself as some sort of hero, a person who is not afraid to speak the truth  about our schools. I believe she has hurt our cause, not helped it. Her unprofessional words make us all look bad. Any of us who speaks out now will be tossed in the same pile — another angry teacher who hates students. It will be assumed that many of us have secret contempt for children, even if we don’t blog about it. Negative comments made to students will be scrutinized. Will I be able to have frank discussion with a student about a failing grade or bad behavior, or will my criticism be seen as insulting and abusive?

There are, as she says, serious problems with the education system in this country. But rather than “opening the door” for serious conversation, she has reinforced the public’s suspicions of teachers. The truth needs to be told, and teachers are the insiders who can describe not only the problems, but potential solutions. I wonder, though, who’s going to listen to us?

Advertisements

2 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. theteachingwhore
    Feb 20, 2011 @ 13:47:05

    I agree with all of your comments. It’s not ethical to make fun of the people who have no choice in being in their situation, which is why my satirical articles are never aimed at the kids. Teachers and administrators and other adults choose to work in the education field, and we are the one who are responsible for what happens there.

    Reply

    • escher dax
      Feb 20, 2011 @ 15:21:26

      Indeed, I have never found any of your satire offensive or unprofessional. Your words hit their intended mark.
      While I am often frustrated with my students (as with my own sons), I do not believe in an imaginary past where all children were motivated, polite, and obedient. Any teacher who is angry that kids are unmotivated and rude should find another line of work.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 14 other followers

%d bloggers like this: